Arizona Cardinals 2011 Season: Which Players Have Been The Biggest Disappointments So Far?
The Arizona Cardinals came into the 2011 season hoping that with a few new additions to the team, a new defensive coordinator and a new mindset, they may be able to return to their winning ways and get back into the playoffs. As all Cardinals fans know, this simply has not been the case. The team is currently sitting on a record of 3-7 with little hope of reaching the postseason.
Not only have some of the new additions underperformed, but some players that were on the roster in years past have not lived up to expectations either. Let's examine some of these players and see what they have (or haven't) done to be recognized as such disappointments to the team.
You may have seen my post earlier this month regarding some of Bradley's downfalls and his performance so far. As of late, Bradley has earned some more time on the field, but he is still not living up to the hype he received when he signed his free agent contract with the Cardinals. Most people feel he should be starting at inside linebacker by now, but Paris Lenon still occupies that role. Bradley has failed to comprehend the 3-4 scheme that Ray Horton utilizes and has been relegated to special teams for most of his time on the field. He has the ability to be a very good player, but his presence has not been felt so far.
We have been over and over the struggles of Kevin Kolb as the new starting quarterback for the Cardinals. Some people even feel that his play has been so poor that John Skelton should be starting over him. He has only played in seven games this season after having to sit out the past three with a turf toe injury. During the games he played, he has thrown 8 TDs, 8 INTs and has completed 56.8% of his passes. He has also fumbled the ball seven times and lost three of them. Kolb struggles to stay in the pocket and deliver the ball to his receivers at times and the offense has struggled to score while he has been in command. He has openly admitted that he does not have the playbook down 100% yet, which could be a big reason for his poor play. With a better understanding of the playbook and improved footwork, Kolb will get better, but he has been disappointing as the team's new QB so far.
Cardinals fans were rejoicing the day they found at that Ken Whisenhunt and Rod Graves decided to bring free agent tight end Todd Heap into the fold. Heap, the local Mountain View High and ASU product, has only played in five games this season, starting two of them. He has been out with a hamstring injury for numerous weeks, making no contribution since he played against the Giants in week 4. He has 13 receptions for 150 yards, but was expected to be a much needed safety net for Kolb and a big red zone target for the Cardinals. If he doesn't come back and show why the team picked him up in the first place, I am not so sure he will return to the team next year.
After the Cardinals were unable to negotiate a deal with numerous free agent wide receivers, Ken Whisenhunt announced that he was going to let his young guys have a chance to fill the role of being the number two receiver, namely Andre Roberts. So far, this looks like it was not the greatest of decisions. Roberts has struggled to become a big contributor in the passing game, allowing defenses to stack players on Larry Fitzgerald. Roberts has 25 catches for 294 yards so far, but we have seen most of these come in the past three weeks with Skelton under center. Kolb and Roberts have been unable to develop a rapport and the team has struggled because of that. Early Doucet has emerged as the better receiving option due to Roberts' poor play. He drops too many passes and he fails to gain separation from opposing cornerbacks far too often.
Levi Brown:
There really isn't much I can say about Levi. Since being drafted fifth overall in the 2007 draft by the Cardinals, Brown has been a consistent turnstile on the offensive line. Pro Football Focus ranks him as the worst pass blocking left tackle in the NFL. He has shown flashes of being a good run blocker, but has been inconsistent at that as well. He allows multiple sacks and incurs numerous penalties. He will not be back with the team next year.
Porter started the first six games of the season as the team's ROLB and was only able to collect one sack during that time. Since rookie Sam Acho has taken over, he has created three sacks and one forced fumble. Porter has been out since week 8 after having his knee scoped. His age shows as he attempts to create pressure on the opposing quarterback. He does not have the quickness or the strength to take on top tier offensive tackles and he fails to disengage from blocks to make plays. Porter is another player that I highly doubt will remain with the team past this season.
Honorable Mention:
Rashad Johnson, Brandon Keith, Richard Marshall, Dan Williams.
Now it's up to you, fans. Who do you think has been the biggest disappointment on the team in the 2011 season? Vote in the poll and leave your comments below.
52 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Levi and Porter aren't disappointments...
THEY ARE WHO WE THOUGHT THEY WERE!!!!!!
by ELrupps on Nov 23, 2011 9:46 AM MST reply actions 1 recs
Exactly
Who had high enough hopes for those two this season that they could possibly be the most disappointing this year?
by CardsFan1976 on Nov 23, 2011 2:17 PM MST up reply actions
Completely disagree...
even with my very low expectations, the have been disappointments, far worse than I thought possible.
Levi's been FAR worse?
He wasn’t good enough to fall far enough to classify his play as “far worse”. That’s like saying a guy who was a 2 on a scale from 1-10 dropping to a 1 is a “huge” drop.
by CardsFan1976 on Nov 23, 2011 2:25 PM MST up reply actions
Kolb is the most obvious (and deserving)
He’s been so much worse than I expected, but maybe he’s still learning the system and he’s still young and the offensive line certainly hasn’t helped (can you hear me trying to convince myself that he doesnt just suck).
Almost his equal though in terms of disappointment though has been this offensive line. When are they finally going to accept that Levi Brown is not a NFL caliber OT? Maybe he can play guard or maybe he just sucks and we need to move on but it baffles me how after all this time, he’s still a starting LT for this team.
Bet big, win big...Welcome to Arizona Kevin Kolb!!!
by Steamin' Beamin' on Nov 23, 2011 10:20 AM MST via mobile reply actions
Agreed
Hopefully we see some improvement once he comes back and going into next season from Kolb.
Arizona Cardinals/Chicago Bears fan
Phoenix Suns, Arizona Diamondbacks, Phoenix Coyotes, Arizona Rattlers fan
[I have always lived in Arizona, dad is from Chicago].
Leading the NFL in swagtangibles
It's not THAT suprising to see Levi still starting,
He didn’t replace a HOF’r, he replaced MIKE GANDY! How he sucks more than Gandy, I cannot comprehend. Idk what AZ did to piss off God so bad that we got cock-blocked from AP, and instead get stuck with Levi “why isn’t my name Charlie?” Brown. That’s like getting your first kiss and catching mono. :(
by lifeinthepit00 on Nov 23, 2011 4:26 PM MST up reply actions
Kolb
It has 2 be kolb he was brought here as the problem solver and I knew he needs to learn the system but its taking longer then we thought and fans are not patient but as long as hes a cardinal ill route for him
by Thbaz on Nov 23, 2011 10:28 AM MST via mobile reply actions
Runner ups
Andre roberts I thought he was going to be better than he is right now and I wouldn’t resign rashad johnson, I would say levi but we all knew he wasn’t any good do not resign him either I think its better if we just cut ties, im really surprise about heap maybe baltimore knew something we didn’t
by Thbaz on Nov 23, 2011 11:03 AM MST via mobile reply actions
Roberts was my #1 vote.
After making him the #2 and not pursuing Breaston or chasing another #2 WR, I thought he’d make some noise this season. But he was practically invisible the entire first half of the season.
by CardsFan1976 on Nov 23, 2011 2:19 PM MST up reply actions
How about Ryan Williams?
not his fault at all but i am dissapointed we couldent use him this year. Would have been a HUGE help to our offense. Cant wait to get him back next year.
Kolb- from what we paid to get him and the return on that investment. We need to see some signs of improvment, which i think will come with time.
Williams has been a disappointment
his situation has just been disappointing. it’s quite a shame that he got injured, he looked really good
Follow me on Twitter at @AlexDavidson68
His injury was a disappointment
Arizona Cardinals/Chicago Bears fan
Phoenix Suns, Arizona Diamondbacks, Phoenix Coyotes, Arizona Rattlers fan
[I have always lived in Arizona, dad is from Chicago].
Leading the NFL in swagtangibles
For me the offensive line is offensive. We knew they were bad last year and thought they would improve please. Saw and liked the idea for the draft, we trade down for anothers first round pick, to get our second round pick back. Let them take a qb we take a stud lineman in the first, go after a pass rusher in second. Then look for other lineman sorry get rid of Grimm, and lets get an offensive coordinator
I said Todd Heap
Simply because I was so excited when we signed him to finally get some nice TE play, and while we haven’t had a bad year at that position the guy just can’t even get on the field. He has just been fighting injuries all season (which I expected some injury but not this bad)
Obviously the runner up has to be Kolb but although he definitely HAS NOT looked good this year, I expected things to take a year to click.
The Answer is Levi Brown
The answer is always Levi Brown. He’s been the answer since we first drafted him in ‘07. If you were look up the word ’disappointment’ in the dictionary, you would find yourself rather disappointed that the definition is not accompanied by a picture of Levi Brown. (not yet anyway)
Talking about this year, not career
Can’t argue that he’s one of the biggest career busts of this team’s Arizona history (out of many, that’s no small feat), but were you really expecting any different this year from Levi?
by CardsFan1976 on Nov 23, 2011 2:34 PM MST up reply actions
You guys need to get off of Levi's back.
He’s not good. But our QB play has really made him seem like he’s worse than he actually is. He hasn’t even messed up much since skeltons been playing…coincidence? I think not. He obviously wasnt worth the high draft pick, but we just need to accept him for who he is: A barely serviceable left tackle.
He definitely hasn’t been disappointing, he’s done exactly what I thought he would do this year, maybe even a little bit more.
by forget on Nov 23, 2011 2:03 PM MST via mobile reply actions
You can't be serious!!!
He hasn’t been even a barely serviceable left tackle, let alone worth a high draft pick. He MIGHT make a barely serviceable guard but then there wouldn’t be a pocket for any of our quarterbacks to step up into.
I'm dead serious.
He’s not as bad as people make him out to be. Everyone just made him the scapegoat early on…
by forget on Nov 23, 2011 2:28 PM MST via mobile up reply actions
As the article mentions, PFF disagrees
And they’re pretty highly regarded. Levi is one of the worst LTs in the entire league. Only reason he seems like a scapegoat is that Warner managed to hide his poor performance during the good years.
by CardsFan1976 on Nov 23, 2011 2:35 PM MST up reply actions
He is one of the worst.
But he still hasnt been that bad. A lot of the sacks he gives up are because of the guy playing quarterback.
I’m not trying to argue that he’s good, im just trying to say he isn’t one of the main reasons for our horrible play this season.
by forget on Nov 23, 2011 2:45 PM MST via mobile up reply actions
I knew we disagreed a lot
But I thought you were able to at least argue your point objectively. Now I see the light. The only way you can call Levi somewhat serviceable is if you are Levi. Good luck this weekend you slow footed fraud of a LT.
If you don't have anything good to say about the Cards this season, you'd be correct.
by hevchv on Nov 23, 2011 5:44 PM MST via mobile up reply actions
Lol
All I’m saying is that the reason Levi has looked so bad is because of the bad QB play. Have you noticed the last 3 games? He really hasn’t messed up a lot. It’s not a coincidence!
I agree we need an improvement for that spot, but he isn’t one of the main reasons why we have struggled this year.
by forget on Nov 23, 2011 5:52 PM MST via mobile up reply actions
Only reason Kolb is the biggest disappointment
is that many people’s expectations of him were too high to start with.
Not saying he hasn’t been disappointing – he has. He should have progressed farther than he has to this point. But seriously, the guy had 7 career starts, had no offseason with the team, and was learning a new system that’s so complicated even Warner said it takes a full year to be comfortable in it. Yet many came in expecting him to play like a top 10 QB immediately and lead the Cards to 10-12 wins. That just wasn’t realistic. Kolb was signed to be developed into the QB of the future; anything this year would have been nice, but wasn’t the ultimate goal.
Testify
Don’t forget the D collapsed completely a couple of times early in the year, most notably against the goddam Giants. Now the defense have their shit together, for the most part. There’s no way that you could consider Skelton preferable to Kolb, even before he shit the bed this week.
Bite off more than you can chew. Then chew it! ~Courage Wolf.
by OntarioCardsFan1977 on Nov 23, 2011 3:34 PM MST up reply actions
You bad mouth Skelton when nobody even brought him up
don’t be like Insomniatic with the blind hate
by CanadianCard on Nov 23, 2011 6:08 PM MST up reply actions
But do no forget that the O-Line has played terribly with Kolb
They’ve only turned it around the last three weeks. If Kolb had the line playing this good he’d have performed better.
Section 103, Row 19
Here's the thing
They’ve been playing the same throughout the whole season. It’s just that Skelton doesn’t cause his own sacks like kolb! Kolb makes this line look bad because if his horrible awareness in the pocket.
by forget on Nov 23, 2011 4:23 PM MST via mobile up reply actions
I can understand that we're all still going to be divided on the whole...
Skelton and Kolb debate. But idk if you really thought through what you just said. You’re really going to say that Kolb is the reason our O-LIne looks bad? What a load… granted I’ll give you the point about Skelton looking better in the pocket (for now) but our O-LIne sucks regardless and is our biggest flaw on this team. I’m sorry but Cardsfan1976 hit the nail on the head. Everyones expectations have been way too high for Kolb right from the start. Give him time and he WILL be good or atleast above average.
Sorry folks, park's closed. Moose out front shoulda told ya.
I'm not going to argue that Skelton should start
Kolb is a little better that Skelton. But I’d still like to know what leads anyone to believe that he will ever be any kind of seviceable starting QB in the NFL.
by Spikedriver on Nov 23, 2011 10:06 PM MST up reply actions
Our biggest flaw is at QB
Half of the sacks on kolb were kolb’s fault. That’s indisputable.
I’m not arguing for Skelton. Both of our guys suck, it doesn’t matter who we play.
by forget on Nov 24, 2011 12:58 AM MST via mobile up reply actions
Okay...
how are you figuring that half of the sacks are kolbs fault? Look at all the good QB’s…… they have an O-Line that allows them to stand in the pocket as long as needed or to atleast make a play. QB is a flaw right now because expectations to produce immediately are too high.
Our O-line is like a wet paper bag and falls apart in seconds. And so that’s Kolbs fault when he get’s sacked? I’m not kidding when I say that I’ve seen better college football O-lines. Granted I’ll give you ONE point about it being Kolbs fault. And that is his pocket presence sucks right now. That too however can be attributed to the O-line.
Sorry folks, park's closed. Moose out front shoulda told ya.
He doesn't get rid if the ball quick enough
And when he leaves the pocket, he often runs straight into the oncoming rush. This is not debatable haha.
You said it falls apart in seconds, you’re right.!three seconds! That’s long enough to get rid if the ball! Lol
by forget on Nov 24, 2011 11:23 AM MST via mobile up reply actions
You're going to tell me this isn't debatable?
First is that our offensive line is worse than when Warner was our QB. And it was bad even then. Currently it’s been ranked on numerous websites as 31st worse offensive line in the league. That’s not debatable and wouldn’t effect a NEW QB’s abilities? Especially one that had no OTA’s, offseason, etc.. Get the hell outta here! Do you consider 31st in the league good?
And when Warner was our QB, he was listed as one of the top ten QB’s who held onto the ball too long. Ill even give you the link to the article
http://www.aolnews.com/2009/09/23/which-quarterbacks-hold-the-ball-too-long/
Yet somehow Warner was able to get the ball out and make plays “eventually” because the O Line allowed him too. The only reason once again that you think Kolb holds onto it too long is because OUR O LINE SUCKS and let’s defenders by and he gets flushed from the pocket. Also our receivers are decent at best except for one… so who the hell is gonna get open for him while he sits in that pocket? Ha, sorry bud but having an elite QB aint gonna solve every problem on “team”. Pssshh, not debatable!
Sorry folks, park's closed. Moose out front shoulda told ya.
Oh yea...
and if you were expecting a QB that runs like Vick you’re delusional. Kolbs mobile, but no running back. What do you expect from him…..
Sorry folks, park's closed. Moose out front shoulda told ya.
HAHAHAHA
ok dude. All you did was google “nfl offensive line rankings”, and then looked at the very first link. That link was a PRESEASON ranking.
Also, READ my post. I said that you cannot debate the fact that Kolb does not get rid of the ball quick enough, and he often scrambles into many sacks. You can debate that our QB is not the biggest flaw on our team, thats your opinion.
warner did hold on to the ball too long at times. But kolb is at another level when it comes to this. the one thing about warner, he got rid of the ball when guys blitzed. He always got rid of it quick! Kolb doesn’t do this.
One of the indicators for holding on to the ball too long is fumbles. Kolb has 6, in 7 games! But you don’t even need stats to know he holds the ball too long. You just have to count! He doesn’t get rid of the ball within 3 seconds! That’s why he’s been sacked so many times!
How can the o-line sucking make me think kolb is holding the ball too long? I just count! lol. Use some reason here!
And i won’t even comment on kolb bailing from the pocket. You are not paying attention to the games, or you probably don’t understand whats going on.
and btw
that link doesn’t provide any good info
it only took stats from like the first two weeks of the season. And it didn’t take into account how many times the QB got sacked. Tom Brady is #2 for holding the ball too long…but he only got sacked once….wooo.
its more of a measurement of how good an o-line is. Like if the sacks are happening in under 2.5 seconds, your o-line is obviously having trouble. If your sacks are over 3 seconds, your o-line is doing a pretty good job. You’d obviously have to gather this data for many more games to make the info useful.
it can be used to evaluate quarterbacks though. For example, brady quinn and trent edwards were sacked 9 and 6 times respectfully, but their times were over 3.2 seconds. They were obviously holding the ball too long.
your google research needs some improvement though, thats two times in your post where you had bad links.
Kolb has been the biggest disappointment so far.
After watching the first 2 games i was getting excited. He looked prettry good and I thought we would just get better. Watching him regress and complete just 51% of his passes his last 4 games was disheartening. I was expecting a polished QB would would have to learn the system, not the play he has demonstrated.
Roberts is a close 2nd for his hands of stone.
by billydacardsfan on Nov 23, 2011 3:53 PM MST reply actions
I think we all expected too much from Kolb
Including me. Also adding in the fact that he was one of the biggest Cardinals trade-pieces in franchise history, he’s the most disappointing. But I’m going to hold my opinion until the end of the season.
Joe Saunders: "They played a really good game, so hats off to us"
Frankly Kolb is living up to exactly what I expected...
average. Williams has been a disappointment because he was suppose to be a premier nose tackle and so far not close. Andre Roberts is a HUGE disappointment because as the number 2 receiver pair with Larry he should have way more receptions and some post game highlights. I never got the sense he was better then Doucet and so far he’s not.
Kolb by a long margin.
I was not expecting top tier play from Kolb either. I also was not expecting to see a guy who looks like he’s having a panic attack half the time. Far too many turnovers and sacks. Too little poise.
Andre Roberts has been a massive letdown. Everyone keeps talking about another receiver stepping up and it’s starting to sound like a euphemism for Andre Roberts sucks. Doucet has done his job. With greater use of the tight end the rest of the receiver depth hasn’t had as much play time as in recent years.
The thing with Roberts is
He is really good with the ball in his hands. We just can’t get it to him. Some of the blame for this should fall on our QBs, but it’s gotta be Roberts fault too.
by forget on Nov 24, 2011 11:29 AM MST via mobile up reply actions
Roberts
has shown some good moves after the catch. He has been almost a non factor though. Only 25 catches in 10 games, less than 300 yards. He’s on pace for under 500 for the season and only about 40 catches. Doucet is on pace for 800-900 yards and nearly 70 catches and he’s on the field a lot less than Roberts. The quarterback play is a factor but one that applies equally. All the talk about needing to create space for Fitz really falls on Roberts when they are in 2 receiver sets, which is most first and second down plays.

by 





















